The Law Offices of Ty Martinez Criminal Defense

Penal Code 1385 PC: Dismissals in the Interest of Justice

Lawyer for PC 1385 motions to dismiss strikes and enhancements in Riverside, San Bernardino, Los Angeles, Orange and Ventura counties.

We have 40+ years of combined experience providing criminal defense in Southern California. Tilting the Scales of Justice in your favor.

See how we defend strike cases.

Reviewed by Ty Martinez, criminal defense attorney, on November 14, 2026.

Penal Code 1385 lets a judge dismiss a case, a charge, an enhancement or a prior strike in the interest of justice. Defense lawyers use it to ask the court to strike a prior strike, called a Romero motion, and to dismiss sentence enhancements. For enhancements, the judge must give great weight to nine listed mitigating circumstances, which weigh greatly in favor of dismissal unless it would endanger public safety.

At a glance
Code sectionCalifornia Penal Code 1385
What it doesLets a judge dismiss a case, a charge, an enhancement or a prior strike in the interest of justice
Who can askThe judge acts on its own or at the prosecutor's request; the defense asks the judge to act
ReasonsMust be stated on the record
Prior strikesCan be dismissed in a Romero motion
EnhancementsDismissed when that is in the interest of justice, unless a voter initiative bars it
Mitigating circumstancesNine listed factors weigh greatly in favor of dismissing an enhancement
Enhancement rules apply toSentencings after January 1, 2022

Charged under PC 1385 in Riverside or San Bernardino County?
Calls are answered 24/7, and the consultation is free.

Call Now: (888) 348-7288

What PC 1385 means

PC 1385 lets a judge dismiss an action in furtherance of justice, on the court's own motion or at the prosecutor's request. The reasons must be stated on the record (PC 1385(a)). Courts read this power broadly: a judge can dismiss a whole case, a single count, or an allegation such as an enhancement or a prior conviction.

The defense cannot formally make the motion, but it can, and usually does, ask the judge to act. A judge cannot dismiss for a reason that would be a ground for a demurrer, that is, a defect in the charging document itself (PC 1385(a)).

If the court can dismiss an enhancement, it can instead strike only the extra punishment for it (PC 1385(b)).

For an enhancement, the judge must give great weight to evidence that any of these mitigating circumstances is present (PC 1385(c)(2)):

  1. The enhancement would have a discriminatory racial impact (PC 745(a)(4))
  2. Multiple enhancements are alleged in one case; the statute says all but one shall be dismissed
  3. The enhancement could result in a sentence of over 20 years; the statute says it shall be dismissed
  4. The current offense is connected to mental illness
  5. The current offense is connected to prior victimization or childhood trauma
  6. The current offense is not a violent felony (PC 667.5(c))
  7. You were a juvenile when you committed the current offense or a prior offense that triggers the enhancement
  8. The enhancement is based on a prior conviction more than five years old
  9. A firearm was used, but it was inoperable or unloaded

Romero motions: dismissing a prior strike

Under the Three Strikes law, one prior serious or violent felony doubles the sentence for a new felony, and two or more can mean 25 years to life. In People v. Superior Court (Romero) (1996) 13 Cal.4th 497, the California Supreme Court held that judges can use PC 1385 to dismiss a prior strike in the interest of justice.

The judge looks at the current offense, your prior record, and your background, character and prospects, and asks whether you fall outside the spirit of the Three Strikes law (People v. Williams (1998) 17 Cal.4th 148). The nine mitigating circumstances in PC 1385(c) do not apply to strikes, because the Three Strikes law is not an enhancement (People v. Burke (2023) 89 Cal.App.5th 237), but the same kinds of facts often matter in a Romero motion.

Dismissing enhancements

PC 1385(c) says the court shall dismiss an enhancement if that is in the furtherance of justice, unless a voter initiative prohibits dismissal. Proof of any listed mitigating circumstance weighs greatly in favor of dismissal unless the court finds that dismissal would endanger public safety, meaning a likelihood of physical injury or other serious danger to others (PC 1385(c)(1), (2)).

The California Supreme Court has held that even the circumstances the statute says shall lead to dismissal do not require it automatically; they weigh greatly in favor of it, and the judge still decides (People v. Walker (2024) 16 Cal.5th 1024). The list is not exclusive, and the court can act before, during or after trial or a plea (PC 1385(c)(3), (4)).

Enhancements often raised in these motions include gun enhancements (PC 12022.5, 12022.53), the five-year serious felony prior (PC 667(a)), great bodily injury (PC 12022.7) and gang enhancements (PC 186.22(b)).

What makes a strong motion

A Romero motion or a motion to dismiss enhancements is built on evidence: records of mental health treatment and trauma, work and family history, letters, programs completed in custody and the age of the prior. We file a written motion with exhibits so the judge has reasons to state on the record.

Related charges

PC 1385 cases in Riverside and San Bernardino counties

Romero motions and motions to dismiss enhancements are heard by the trial judge, usually before sentencing or during plea negotiations, and the District Attorney's Office can oppose them. In San Bernardino County, cases from Rancho Cucamonga, Ontario, Upland, Chino, Chino Hills, Montclair, Fontana and Rialto are heard at the West Valley courthouse in Rancho Cucamonga; cases from San Bernardino, Colton, Highland, Redlands, Loma Linda and Yucaipa at the San Bernardino Justice Center; and cases from Victorville, Hesperia and Apple Valley at the Victorville courthouse. In Riverside County, criminal cases are heard at five courthouses: the Riverside Hall of Justice, the Southwest Justice Center in Murrieta, the Banning Justice Center, the Larson Justice Center in Indio and the Blythe courthouse.

Whether a strike or an enhancement stays in a case can change a sentence by many years. Our office is in Riverside, and Yvonne Todd began her career as a Public Defender in San Bernardino.

Frequently asked questions

What is a Romero motion?

A request asking the judge to dismiss a prior strike under PC 1385, so you are sentenced as if you did not have it. The California Supreme Court allowed it in People v. Superior Court (Romero) (1996) 13 Cal.4th 497.

Can the defense file a PC 1385 motion?

PC 1385 lets the judge act on its own or at the prosecutor's request. The defense asks the judge to use that power, usually in a written motion.

Which enhancements can be dismissed?

Most can be, if dismissal is in the furtherance of justice, unless a voter initiative prohibits it (PC 1385(c)(1)).

Does the judge have to dismiss an enhancement if a mitigating circumstance applies?

No, but the circumstance weighs greatly in favor of dismissal unless the judge finds that dismissal would endanger public safety (PC 1385(c)(2); People v. Walker (2024) 16 Cal.5th 1024).

Can a judge dismiss a whole case under PC 1385?

Yes, in the furtherance of justice, with the reasons stated on the record. It cannot be for a defect that should have been raised by demurrer (PC 1385(a)).

Read the official text of PC 1385 on the California Legislative Information site.

This page is general information about California law, not legal advice about your case. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Browse the California Criminal Code

Looking for a different charge? Type a code number or a few words, or jump to a code on the California Criminal Code page.

Facing PC 1385 charges? Calls are answered 24/7, and the consultation is free.

Why clients hire us

  • 25+ years defending criminal cases. Ty Martinez started in criminal law as a deputy public defender.
  • 40+ years of combined experience between Ty Martinez and Yvonne Todd.
  • Calls are answered 24/7, and your first consultation is free.

Meet Your
Lawyers

Let us help you!

    * Required

    OK to leave a voicemail? *

    Read our Privacy Policy to see how we handle what you send.

    Attorney advertising. This website is published by The Law Offices of Ty Martinez, 7121 Magnolia Ave, Riverside, CA 92504. Ty Martinez, a California-licensed attorney, is responsible for its content.

    The information on this site is general information, not legal advice about your situation. Contacting us through this site or by phone does not create an attorney-client relationship, so please do not send confidential details until we have agreed to represent you.

    Reviews and testimonials describe individual clients' experiences. They are not a guarantee, warranty, or prediction regarding the outcome of your legal matter. Any result described on this site depended on the facts of that case, and results will differ if based on different facts.